“I never let my schooling interfere with my education.” —  Mark Twain

The barn was built by Andrew Jackson Hollibaugh in the 1800s. AJ was a great grandfather to my wife, Mary Ellen. He was a barn builder who came to Michigan from Pennsylvania to practice his trade.

Two of his forebears, the Coyles, had been captured in the Civil War, and imprisoned at the notorious Confederate Andersonville POW camp. Most of the Yankee prisoners did not survive. One of the Coyle cousins escaped, and the other perished as a Union soldier in a Confederate POW camp. There is a grave marker at the site of the old camp.

Andrew Jackson Hollibaugh brought a distinctive barn building style with him. The barns he constructed in the area near Cadillac are easily identified by the curved roof lines. Some still stand, with one especially fine example viewable from southbound US-131, near Reed City and Big Rapids. Another surviving barn is on the north side of 20 Mile, east of Tustin.

The family homestead was in the Dighton area, between Tustin and Marion, 15 miles south of the big city of Cadillac, coincidently where some of my family — Eldon Brisbois and Roy Garvin — lived. Andrew J. Hollibaugh built a barn on the homestead, which stood, neglected and in disrepair, until somewhat recently. The barn had finally tumbled down, but the new owners of the property were nice enough to tolerate us acquiring a stone from the foundation. In the family archives, we found some old photos of the barn when it was strong and functional.

I’m guessing that the foundation stone weighs 30 pounds. I took it to Black Monument Company in Grand Rapids and had them letter it. It turned out beautifully, and Mary Ellen likes it very much. Other family members will see photos of it, and, perhaps see it on the front porch of our home. The Black Monument people tell me that the stone was unusually hard. It’s flat on top and bottom, and has one side that is very straight, as if having been worked. It’s variegated gray, with some orangish red flecks. My best guess is that it’s granite.

Beards have seen an uptick in fashionability recently, and Andrew Jackson Hollibaugh would have certainly had some bragging rights. He achieved a big beard. Andrew was known to part his beard at the chin, and tie the two sections behind his back, when working on ladders.

Alfred Letson Hollibaugh, son of the barn builder, played baseball for the Dighton team. Every small town had their own team then, and Dighton played against teams from other communities for local pride. We have a photo from the game that was played July 4, 1904. A.L. Hollibaugh in the photo is posed with a ball in his hand. He became the grandfather of my wife. I take him to be a pitcher, the only player shown holding a ball. Like our very own David Young, in his youth he hurled.

The photo of which I speak was taken in a stand of white pine. The men wore uniforms, baggy flannels with DIGHTON emblazoned on the chest. Half the men wore neckties. The mitts of the day were looked flat and cushiony, and they lacked webbing. The fingers of the gloves do not appear laced together. There is a bat in the photo, and it looks hand carved. Seeing that bat makes me think of Wonderboy, the bats used by Roy Hobbs in Bernard Malamud’s novel are part of the story line in “The Natural.” The 1984 movie version, by the same title, received four academy awards. Yes, Walter, as you well know, there were two handmade bats.

In the Sherman Township Cemetery there is a special grave marker, a large edifice constructed to show the distinctive roof line of a Hollibaugh barn.

10 Comments

Robert M Traxler
August 15, 2017
Mr. Basura, Good work on the family history, barn builders were rock stars of their day. Dig a bit deeper and you may find a connection to the Revolutionary War; the government, not having any money, gave veterans land grants of some 160 acres in Western New York and Pennsylvania. The children and grandchildren of veterans moved west in the 1800s for free or cheap land. The opening of the Erie Canal in 1825 allowed people and goods to move into out of the Michigan Territory at the blistering speed of 5-6 miles per hour. Love to see more on the ancestor who escaped from Andersonville; hundreds of miles behind enemy lines in a hostile territory, probably sick and starving, it took a heck of a soldier to escape.
Basura
August 16, 2017
Thank you for the interesting and informative comments, Bob. The Coyles got off the boat from Ireland, and found themselves wearing blue uniforms shortly thereafter. Both escaped from Andersonville. One made it back, one was recaptured and died in the camp. Conditions at Andersonville were horrific.
August 16, 2017
The good people at the Then & Now Historical Library came up with a photo of the Hollibaugh headstone. I'll give it to you when I see you next.
Basura
August 17, 2017
Wow! Thank you, and thank those good folks too.
Bill Shust
March 26, 2018
Hello Mr. Young, I've just stumbled onto this column today (3/26/18). AJH was also my 2nd great grandfather. AJH's daughter Cora married my great grandfather Chancey Shust, and they resided in Paris, MI. I understand that his barns were unique in that area of Michigan, known for a rounded roof, and I have some photos of 4 or 5 existing barns that I believe he built. Very interesting to read your article. Sincerely, Bill Shust, Naperville, IL
February 22, 2021
My name is Richard Scovel and this article is about my grandfather and great grandfather - my mother was the daughter of Alfred Letson Hollibaugh and i loved grandpa dearly -
Thomas M Scovel
February 22, 2021
I am a direct descendant of AJ Hollibaugh. My mother's name was Evelyn Letson Hollibaugh.
February 22, 2021
My name is Richard Scovel and this article is about my grandfather and great grandfather - I live in Maysville Wva and would enjoy talking with someone about this article 304-995-5612
Thomas M Scovel
February 23, 2021
To clarify my Hollibaugh relationship a little better, A J Hollibaugh is my great grandfather, and Alfred Letson Hollibaugh my grandfather and best friend. Evelyn Letson (Hollibaugh) Scovel was my mother. Richard Scovel is my younger brother and Marjorie (Scovel) Nail our sister. I was born in Lansing, MI, and currently live outside Grand Rapids, MI. My family and I have toured the Dighton, MI, area and cemeteries and saw a few of the barns that were left. There was a book written by Larry Wakefield in 1994, published by Northmont Publishing, Inc., entitled Ghost Towns of Michigan where Dighton has it's own chapter.
Thomas M Scovel
February 24, 2021
Can anyone shed some light on where the name "Letson" comes from? We've been curious for many years. Thanks, Tom

Post your comment

Discover more from

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading