by Lynn Mandaville
In the land of hyperbole, Doug Jones, in a landslide victory, was victorious over Roy Moore to clinch the coveted senate seat in Alabama Tuesday, a seat made vacant when Jeff Sessions accepted appointment to the cabinet position of Attorney General for the Trump administration.
In truth, however, this highly controversial election was won by a very narrow margin.
What the pundits will make of this I have no idea. But, as I write this in the wee hours of Wednesday morning, to many of us this victory signals a ray of hope that, even if Republican legislators don’t put country before party, the voters of Alabama do. The good people of Alabama worked exceedingly hard to get out the vote in favor of high moral standards over partisan politics.
These good people said, in essence, that the word of young girls was to be believed when spoken by their adult selves at a time when a long-awaited cultural shift was occurring in America regarding attitudes toward and practices of unwanted sexual behavior.
To be truthful, I did not expect a Doug Jones victory to be the outcome of this election. I had expected that I would be writing that the continued victimization of the less powerful among us would continue to be America’s normal. Instead, I have the opportunity to cheer what I hope to see become the resurrection of real morality, the restoration of true respect, and the heightened level of participatory democracy in America.
In my not-so-humble opinion, I think, as a nation, we have become too quick to anger, too quick to judge, and too fast to shoot off our mouths. I think that our hypocrisy has blossomed as quickly as a red tide to the point that some of us proclaim our Christianity with voices loud and shrill while in our hearts we think that kindness and compassion are for suckers and saps.
I have observed for a long time (decades, in fact), that we, men and women alike, have allowed ourselves to become a nation of victims. We have become so emotionally needy and self-centered that we have become weaker rather than stronger. I view the emergence of #MeToo as a shift away from that victimhood, at least for women who have experienced sexual harassment and kept it silent for much too long.
If you read my piece last week, you know I shared my own stories of the inappropriate behavior of two men toward me when I was a girl. I never thought of myself as a victim of anything. I thought of myself as having figured out how to protect myself from similar behavior in my future, and as having put it behind myself so as to move forward.
Now, with the preponderance of stories like my own, I have a sense that women are speaking up now, not as victims, per se, but as significant statistics to support our fight for equality, equity, and justice.
We all know that the Alabama election does not mark an end to this chapter in our social history. In coming weeks we will continue to see more prominent men outed for acting on their baser impulses. We will have to grapple with ambiguous feelings toward men whom we have admired and respected on one hand, and now are repulsed by on the other. We will have to try to become reconciled with the seeming unfair application of punishment imposed by the court of public opinion in the absence of due process.
In the airing of all this cultural dirty laundry, many new questions have arisen regarding how we will move forward and morally higher. In the area of news casting and reporting, who will replace the fallen men? Will the face of morning news shows be female for a while? Will future male morning show performers have to be vetted as to their moral standing? Will there now be a new form of background checks for men?
Besides clearing them from immoral conduct with children, as in school or daycare settings, will they have to be subjected to clearing of immoral conduct with women? (Or men, as this type of behavior certainly isn’t isolated to the treatment of women by men, but of men by men.) Will we now have perverted office pools where people bet on which man will be outed next, in what industry he will be employed, and of what type of offense he will be accused?
For me, one unsettling thing remains. I watch the news shows and view popular culture with a sense of dread, not that there will be more men accused, but that the men accused will be more of those I admire. Will it be long-respected Lester Holt, or squeaky clean John Dickerson? Will Scott Simon of NPR be tarnished? Will a renowned chef or actor or author or intellectual turn out to be scum? Will it be someone in my local government or on my school board? A neighbor? A relative? It’s almost enough to turn a wide-eyed optimist into a jaded misanthrope.
I say almost because I remain Pollyanna in many ways. I believe we have it within us to rise above the fever dream that envelops us. I believe that within us lies dormant the lesson we learned as children, either in church or school or at our parents’ feet. Do unto others what you would have them do unto you. We just need to rouse it from its sleep.
Ms. Mandaville,
I think you will find the link below interesting. It’s an account by Dr. Judith Curry of academic misogyny in the ’70s and ’80s. And what she did, as someone who became a leader despite the discrimination, to address some of the issues. None of her actions involved acting as a victim. There’s also a look at viewpoint discrimination; to which she is currently subject.
From Wikipedia:
“Curry was a Professor and former Chair of the School of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences at the Georgia Institute of Technology; she held the latter position from 2002 to 2013.[8] Curry serves on NASA Advisory Council Earth Science Subcommittee whose mission is to provide advice and recommendations to NASA on issues of program priorities and policy. She is a recent member of the NOAA Climate Working Group[8][9] and a former member of the National Academies Space Studies Board and Climate Research Group.[8][10]
Curry is a former professor of Atmospheric and Oceanic Sciences at the University of Colorado-Boulder and has held faculty positions at Penn State University, Purdue, and the University of Wisconsin-Madison.[8][10] Curry has been active in researching possible connections between hurricane intensity and global warming.[11][12] Her research group has also done research linking the size of hurricanes and resulting damage that showed that, among other things, the size of the hurricanes was an important factor in determining the number of tornadoes spawned by the system.[13]
Curry is the co-author of Thermodynamics of Atmospheres and Oceans (1999),[14] and co-editor of Encyclopedia of Atmospheric Sciences (2002).[15] Curry has published over 130 scientific peer reviewed papers.[16] Among her awards is the Henry G. Houghton Research Award from the American Meteorological Society in 1992.[16]”
_Girl’s Rules_
Dr. Judith Curry
https://judithcurry.com/2017/12/10/girls-rules/
Thank you so much for this article. I found it of great interest and enlightenment. I’m so glad a woman of such stature is also speaking about resisting victimhood. It is something from which all men and women can benefit.