ACHTUNG: This is not a fair and balanced article. It is an editorial by the editor.

 “Oh, what a tangled web we weave when at first we practise to deceive.” — Sir Walter Scott

Public schools have been under fire for a spell, some of it undeserved, some of it deserved. I’ve been an almost life-long supporter of public schools, especially in the face of well-funded lopsided challenges from private, charter and religious education.

But when public school officials tell us on one hand that transparency is of the utmost importance, then conveniently leave out critical information when something controversial happens, there is a serious problem.

When such instances arise, I see public schools as being no different than corporate entities that too often won’t give the unwashed masses the straight poop. They sometimes fall into that bloody awful manufactured public relations habit that’s reminiscent of “He resigned to spend more time with his family.”

I’m particularly disappointed in recent announcements of high school football games being canceled. In these times when Covid is king, it often is the reason why the contests have been called off. So say so.

However, in recent local developments, the official (corporate) line is that the game “has been cancelled due to unforeseen circumstances” with no explanation of the reason — Covid 19.

The first time I noticed a ballgame called off was a regularly scheduled football matchup between Martin and Lawrence. It turned out that at least one of the Clippers had tested positive for the Coronavirus.

There is no shame in this. In fact, school officials should be lauded for avoiding the risk of spreading the disease any further.

Strangely, Martin returned to the gridiron on a Saturday afternoon to play a team it defeated in its season opener, Tri-Unity Christian. I am told the contest was arranged hastily, just one night after Martin’s second cancellation, against Marcellus, had been called off.

Then came the news that the regular season finale, at Bangor, was canceled. This time, the reason was that the host school had begged off competing.

Then came the news this week that undefeated Hopkins had to cancel its Parents’ Night home game against O-K Silver Conference opponent Kelloggsville, which had a snowball’s chance in Hades of beating the Vikings on the field. Hopkins had at least one player test positive and the forfeit mars and otherwise spotless campaign.

My point here is that school officials are doing themselves and their communities no favors by not coming out immediately and presenting the reason for the cancellation. Telling the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth goes a long way in advancing the public’s trust in the public school system, by living up to the promise of transparency.

Acting like corporate entities and somehow obscuring the truth at the outset sows the awful seeds of mistrust.

So, I implore public schools to act like public schools, stand for the truth and quit acting like corporations.

 

5 Comments

Lynn E Mandaville
October 25, 2020
It is a sad thing, to me, that mistrust in all aspects of bureaucratic institutions has grown over the past three and a half years. We have seen mistrust encouraged by the president through his attacks on the intelligence community, the Democratic Party, his own cabinet members, and anyone whom he feels has slighted him. He has encouraged mistrust of well-meaning protesters while at the same time causing us to mistrust police and military who are sent out to mistreat those protesters. Mistrust trickles down to local government and, ultimately, to the schools, who are trying so hard to balance the contradictory demands of parents. School systems don't help themselves by shrouding the truth. Citizens don't need protection from the truth, as Trump would have us believe regarding COVID-19. And parents don't need protection from news of appearances of the virus. Sounds trite, but the truth does set us free. It doesn't fetter us.
Harry Smit
October 25, 2020
Ms Mandaville A very interesting article. In your belief mistrust basically is the fault of our current President (very interesting indeed). If you truly believe the truth sets us free: Why has public education well before our current President not taught true history? We all are aware the majority of people can not handle the truth. The history of our country is not pleasant reading about getting to where we are now. Requires knowing multitudes of atrocities committed against not only those in the United States, but actions all over the planet. We are no longer a people who can acccept that we made a mistake. It always seems to be someone else or other factors. In regards to this Covid-19 virus: Yes the citizens needed protection. This virus is real. Just because one has followed all the recommendations and safety guidelines doesn't mean you will not die from it. It just means you didn't die earlier, over tax the health care system, just possibly that first original number of deaths was the truth... But no one wanted to test it. Instead we locked down in hopes of surviving. Truth is a hard pill to swallow and few if any can accept the truth.
Lynn E Mandaville
October 25, 2020
Mr. Smit, I reject your claim that most people cannot accept the truth. Most people can accept the truth, it's just that some can accept it sooner than others. With the proper approach people can be eased into truth if easing is necessary. I've never known anyone who said "I wish the doctor had withheld the truth from me."
Harry Smit
October 26, 2020
Ms Mandaville So according to your response to me. What President Trump is doing is just easing those who can't accept the truth into not worrying about dying. It seems to be working because most think masking up is a joke, the virus is no worse than the flu, and a vaccine is just around the corner. The truth is you are born to die. But no one wants to die so we have doctors, scientists, everyone in the medical community finding ways to keep us alive longer. Though try as they may, no one can keep us alive for ever. It's when we accept that someone or something greater than us controls when and how we will die do we understand the meaning of truth.
Lynn E Mandaville
October 27, 2020
You completely miss my point. Trump didn't even want to ease us into it. He wanted to deny and lie, over and over. If he had been truthful he could have made correct statements in a non-alarming matter. But that's not his style. Anything he says is extreme to one end of the spectrum or the other. Either there is a virus that's severe, a real killer, or there is nothing out there any worse than an ordinary flu. Because he speaks in superlatives there is simply no middle ground, no tact, no diplomacy, no softening of the message. That's my point. People can handle the truth, particularly when one is aware of the power of words and the way in which they are delivered. Deception or misdirection are unnecessary. I wish Trump knew that.

Post your comment

Discover more from

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading