It seems like for the longest time I’ve believed that if a piece of music has words, they’d better be meaningful. I’ve been a huge fan of instrumental music, even in my earliest years of listening.

My love of music without words spilled over into the classical genre late in my teens, but I look and hear back fondly on a small, select group of popular songs in the 1960s and ‘70s.

Submitted for your approval, my list of 15 intelligent and thoughtful songs:

  • “Where Have All the Flowers Gone” 1962, as recorded by the Kingston Trio. One of the earliest folk rock tunes to question the reasons for war.
  • “Little Boxes,” 1963, as recorded by the Pete Seeger and written by Malvina Reynolds. I didn’t understand it back then, but since then I’ve grown to appreciate its message, best used with the TV series “Weeds.”
  • “Like a Rolling Stone,” 1965, as written and recorded by Bob Dylan. Astonishing rhyming while remaining true to the message and attitude.
  • “Eve of Destruction,” 1965, as recorded by Barry McGuire. Much-maligned iconic anti-war song that jump started a musical movement.
  • “Nowhere Man,” 1966, as recorded by the Beatles, as written by John Lennon and Paul McCartney. Rings true for too many Americans today.
  • “Dangling Conversation,” 1966, as written and recorded by Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel. An excellent portrayal of a crumbling marriage with haunting imagery.
  • “Those Were the Days,” 1968, as recorded by Miriam Hopkin. A savage and accurate indictment on the failure of my generation to change the world. It still wounds me deeply when I hear it.
  • “Both Sides Now,” 1969, as written by Joni Mitchell and recorded by Judy Collins. Neatly summarizes how little we know about what’s important.
  • “War,” 1970, as recorded by Edwin Starr. Unapologetic attack on war as immoral and useless. I doubt it could become a hit song today.
  • “Cherokee People (The Lament of an Indian Reservation),” 1971, as recorded by Paul Revere & the Raiders. A teen heart-throb group shocks just about everybody with a thoughtful and sympathetic shout out to Native Americans.
  • “Vincent,” 1972, as written and recorded by Don McLean. An emotional and insightful tribute to the great artist Vincent Van Gogh.
  • “Cat’s in the Cradle,” 1974, as written an recorded by Harry Chapin. A troubling assessment of a relationship between father and son, and an indictment on materialistic priorities.
  • “At Seventeen,” 1975, as written and recorded by Janis Ian. She tore the cover off the phony social hierarchy of high school and exposed the unfair plight of “ugly duckling girls like me.”
  • “Send in the Clowns,” 1977, as recorded by Judy Collins. A haunting and gentle tale about wisdom gained too late.
  • “Dust in the Wind,” 1978, as recorded by Kansas. Oh, the futility of it all.

“All the memories came flooding back…” — Vivian Stanshall.

6 Comments

Lynn Mandaville
December 21, 2017
Oh, David, you've unlocked the music of my younger self. All fifteen choices would be on my list, but my list would go on and on and on. (Maybe yours does, too.) Thanks for the memories, as Bob Hope would sing.
Walt Tarrow
December 21, 2017
I’ll always love the words to Rachmaninoff’s Piano Concerto No. 2
December 21, 2017
That would be "All By Myself," by that scoundrel Eric Carman.
December 21, 2017
Hurricane by Bob Dylan. Society' Child by Janis Ian...... And the beat goes on as the Sonny and Cher sang to us. Love it.......
Pat Brewer
December 22, 2017
Dave, did you ever listen to "A Daisy a Day" by Jed Strunk? Please check it out. I promise that even though he plays a banjo, he does not sing through his nose. It is a nice song about commitment.
Lynn Mandaville
December 22, 2017
Pat, I love that song, too.

Post your comment

Discover more from

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading